This much I know about…the politicisation of education in England

I have been teaching for 24 years now and at the age of 48, this much I know about the politicisation of education in England…

I make no apology for being overtly political when it comes to education. The politicians started it. Education is so obviously a political football and it is time Headteachers started parking the bus and defending in numbers.

I knew that the last election would affect me professionally more than any other. It was clear that Tory education policy would see the effective dismantling of state education as we know it. If they win the next election we will look back on these years and think they were a cinch in comparison to what they will do next to our education system.

Even by the time I got to university I couldn’t understand why intelligent people were right-wing; I always thought everyone should have an equal chance to succeed, and still do. It took a young lecturer in the English department at York to point out that the right have a different fundamental starting point, survival of the fittest. It’s important to remember that every single Tory policy decision has that mantra at its core.

Anyone who has played 5-a-side against me knows that I’m hellishly competitive! I lead a school where we have competitive sports in spades. However, I refuse to compete with other schools. If you take pleasure in other schools not doing as well as yours on examination results day, you are taking pleasure in young people not doing as well as your young people, something which is philosophically and morally indefensible. Collaborate rather than compete – it’s the only way.

I won’t renew my Labour Party membership until I hear their education policy outlined in detail. They haven’t even been able to highlight the differences between Blair’s Academies project and the Coalition’s Academies deception. Twigg’s ineptness in the face of Gove’s onslaught has been breath-taking.

All ruling parties centralise. Baker’s Gerbil in 1988 introduced 365 new centralised powers. Whilst Gove says subsidiarity is best he practises the opposite philosophy. I know some Academy Headteachers who have suddenly realised that when you convert to Academy status you end up with Michael Gove as your Head of Children’s Services.

OFQUAL and OFSTED’s independence from the politicians is palpable nonsense. Gove admits he has told Glenys Stacey that standards must be maintained; whilst I agree entirely with those sentiments, that sounds like instruction from the Secretary of State to me. When Gove claimed OFSTED was independent from Government at the ASCL conference this year, a hall full of Headteachers laughed at him loud and long.

Define your own success. When OFSTED turn up bombard them with evidence which shows why you are successful. Everyone likes success so be very clear about why your school, in its current context, is a success, and repeat the success message relentlessly.

An educationalist I admire greatly is called, ironically, David Cameron! If you don’t follow him on Twitter, I recommend him unreservedly – @realdcameron. He said to me recently, when I expressed concern about this summer’s results, “Revel in your sense of responsibility and pity the narrowness of some of those who judge you and your school.” Such wisdom is a rare commodity.

This politically charged time is the time to stick to our values and get on with getting on, doing all we can for our young people. I know I go on about this a lot, but when so many certainties about education are being undermined, our core purpose and values-system will be all that remain.

Headteachers need to trust their colleagues more than ever. Seneca said, “The first step towards making people trustworthy is to trust them.” In the climate of fear which this government has so brilliantly cultivated it is too easy to threaten staff in response to being threatened oneself. Headteachers have to do the opposite. At our school we deliver over 2,000 lessons each week; I cannot teach them all, so what I have to do is develop my colleagues in a safe school environment which allows them to thrive professionally and personally. It’s the only way I will keep my job.

About johntomsett

Headteacher in York. All views are my own.
This entry was posted in General educational issues. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to This much I know about…the politicisation of education in England

  1. Steve says:

    An admirably clear and persuasive blog post. Thank you.

  2. Geoff Barton says:

    A stunning piece of writing, Mr T, at a very challenging (and unfair) time for many in education, not least those who are most vulnerable or in the most challenging circumstances.

  3. Simona Mckenzie says:

    Very pertinent comment I would like to bring attention to the fact that the Early Years workforce too is undergoing huges changes from September and yet no one has come out in support of what is being imposed on us and which leaves us confused: deregulation or less regulation?
    As we are early years educators I feel we should support each other if, indeed, we are in this together

  4. behrfacts says:

    I think there is an even bigger case for removing politics from education rather than ramping up the inter-party noise on this particular incident, concerning though it is. I used to be a committed Liberal Democrat but always avoided party membership and only really got involved in the 1997 GE when we all wanted a change from John Major. But I’m afraid the same happened under Gordon Brown 13 years later – “plus ca change”. David Laws should have been SoS (or at least a senior minister) for Education and I have blogged about Vince Cable recently, who has a claim to at least genuine higher education teaching experience in the Coalition Cabinet, but even then I would keep him and other MPs at arms length. If Ofqual and Ofsted are independent (and assuming we need them) then politicians cannot play football with them and we will all be guided by the proper needs of the system, preferably at a localised level. Until then ….

  5. Mark Wallace says:

    “Even by the time I got to university I couldn’t understand why intelligent people were right-wing”

    What a narrow-minded, bigoted view. It’s quite disturbing that a teacher can hold such an opinion, and not realise that perhaps, just perhaps, others who disagree with you might have valid, evidence-based reasons for thinking differently.

    The idea the Right are based on “survival of the fittest” is simply untrue – that’s political thinking worthy of the Young Ones.

    • johntomsett says:

      I was 18 and from a rural village. I can understand why intelligent people are right wing. I find some views of the left hugely irritating at times. I can understand entirely that people who disagree with me have valid, evidence-based reasons for thinking differently. I never said they couldn’t – you did.

  6. TDowson says:

    “I make no apology for being overtly political when it comes to education. The politicians started it. Education is so obviously a political football and it is time Headteachers started parking the bus and defending in numbers”.

    I think that the whole teaching profession needs to be behind this one!

  7. Pingback: Football, Soccer and sport. | travellingcoral

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s