This much I know about…how stopping Year 11 interventions will help protect our mental health and improve our well-being

I have been a teacher for 27 years, a Headteacher for 12 years and, at the age of 51, this much I know about how stopping Year 11 interventions will help protect our mental health and improve our well-being.

Stop the interventions. We had a Staff Briefing on Friday, the slides from which are below, where Jane Elsworth and I gave a short presentation to colleagues. Our message was simple: stop doing extra revision sessions for Year 11 and instead save your energies for planning and teaching great lessons which will prepare the students well for their examinations in June. I looked historically at our results which improved from 2010, the year we decided that we should stop extra revision classes. I was worried that provision of the extra stuff was beginning to creep back. Our argument was encapsulated in this sentence:

Why do some students think, when they have seven hours of English lessons in Years 10 and 11 a fortnight, that ten one hour lessons, one a week leading up to the examinations, held after school when they and their teachers are tired, will suddenly transform them from D grade students to C grade students and make up for their lack of effort in their seven hours of lessons a fortnight over the past 18 months?

Stop passing the pressure on. Jane looked at two students, one who is doing 26 hours a week in extra study and one who is in school until 5.30 pm most days of the week, and talked about how we must try to prevent the pressure we feel being passed onto the students. With a high-stakes terminal examination system Headteachers can sometimes pass on the pressure to Subject Leaders who pass it onto their colleagues who pass it on to their students who then can worry their poor parents silly. We need to prevent that. Nothing is worth getting ill about. Let’s just do as well as we can possibly do in a balanced, reasonable way. Don’t get me wrong, there are some students who haven’t woken up yet to the fact that we are eight weeks away from the beginning of the GCSE examinations and who need to do significantly more work, but that is a different issue.

Well-being is of prime importance, because if you and your students are pressured to the point of stress then no one will perform well; crucially, the converse is true. I said this to finish: “All I can ask is that, on results day in August, we can truthfully say to ourselves that we did the very best we could without damaging our own mental health or the mental health of our students. We must not push for even better examination results at the cost of our well-being.” It went down well.

About johntomsett

Headteacher in York. All views are my own.
This entry was posted in General educational issues, School Leadership, Teaching and Learning. Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to This much I know about…how stopping Year 11 interventions will help protect our mental health and improve our well-being

  1. Brian says:

    Now that is real leadership.

  2. J Russell says:

    Heartening sentiments and a must-read for many leaders.

  3. Jo B says:

    Better for everyone…I wish!

  4. Not only have interventions increased stress and workload, they have promoted dependence and spoon feeding and reduced the extra curricular offer.

    Rather than TEACHING interventions, perhaps we should focus on LEARNING interventions earlier, by which I mean identify the students who benefit least from lessons and help them to access the learning better, thereby reducing the need for extra lessons later.

  5. misslisa67 says:

    I really feel for staff, some of whom I work among, who feel pressurised into these waves of intervention throughout yr11. As the Venns are brought out in briefing and the numbers of ‘less than expected’s are displayed, and the names read out, I can feel my colleagues bidding farewell to their lunchtimes, after-school prep time even holiday days. We shouldn’t be supporting this. It’s unpaid additional work and it’s unfair on teachers who are already strung out and overwrought. I believe in my own teaching and I have a long term plan to enable me to cover the syllabus with time to spare for exam practice and revision. My classes know they have to work to succeed, and when they do, we all enjoy ourselves along the way.
    Thanks, John, for protecting teachers and supporting good teaching.
    @Lisa7Pettifer

  6. Pingback: Space, structure and support – getting students exam ready | Chris Eyre on Teaching

  7. Pingback: Intervention sessions ‘harm students’ mental health’ : Skills & Education Group

  8. Pingback: This much I know about whether stopping extra revision sessions after school works (and why we don’t need Grammar Schools) | johntomsett

  9. John Bald says:

    I am really concerned at the amount of stress involved in coursework, including excessive preparation for controlled assessments. In the experience of the pupils I teach (pro bono) – who, in fairness, would not come to me if they did not need help, the stress of continuous assessment, in which they have a high stakes test almost every week for four years to A level, is worse. I know of a school in which this is made worse by senior management, who will not accept any controlled assessment that is below a student’s target grade, however this is done.

  10. Pingback: Seis tácticas para ayudar a tus estudiantes a manejar el estrés – CIUDAD EDUCATIVA

  11. Pingback: Can We Do More With Less? | thinkingreadingwritings

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s